Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Saturday, September 26, 2009

Cold as Ice - History/Tradition of the NFC North

And we continue with the history/tradition category of the team ratings.  Again, this is a major category of the ratings portion, making up 20 of the 100 points. With that said, we look at the coldest division in the NFL:

NFC North

Chicago Bears - 9 NFL Championships, more NFL Hall of Famers than any other team, and one of the charter members of the NFL. The Monsters of the Midway were a powerhouse of the early NFL, winning 7 titles in the NFL's first 26 years. The Bears followed this with only moderate success over the next 40 years...then came the 80's...

Led by Coach Ditka, Jim McMahon, the Fridge, and Walter Payton, the 1985 Bears were not only dominant on the field, but in pop culture as well. Their incredibly awful rap "Super Bowl Shuffle" (enjoy it here) rose to #41 on the Billboard charts and they were immortalized in one of the greatest SNL skits of all time. Their on-field prowess was just as legendary, as they are still the measuring stick for great defensive teams.

While the Bears 9 NFL Championships is undeniably great, only one has come in the Super Bowl era. Still, that 1985 team carries historic weight matched by few teams.

16/20

Detroit Lions - The Lions history hasn't been ALL bad.  They did win 3 NFL titles in the 1950's.  They did have one of the most exciting players of all time in Barry Sanders.  That counts for something, right?

Still, outside of the 50s, futile would be a nice way to describe the Lions.  Sure they had a nice run of playoff teams in the 90s, but won only ONE playoff game (and that's all they've won since 1957). They're the only team to ever go 0-16 and their draft blunders are legendary.

The best thing going for the Lions history, the Thanksgiving Day game.  Still, it'd be nice if they weren't an underdog in that game from time to time. To be fair, 4 NFL titles are still more than a lot of teams can claim and the Lions history is a little better than its reputation, but these last 50 years have hurt.

6/20

Green Bay Packers - The Packers have the most NFL Championships (12), probably the greatest coach in NFL history, and by far the best ownership in the NFL history, so forgive me if I don't do their history justice in 2 or 3 paragraphs. Let's start with ownership. In an effort to keep the financially-strapped franchise in the small town of Green Bay, the team was literally sold to the fans. Currently 112,120 Packers fans share ownership of the team, with no one possessing a majority share. Talk about a vested interest...


The most dominant of the Packers' eras was without a doubt the 60s. Vince Lombardi led the Packers to 5 NFL titles between 1960 and 1967 including wins in the first ever Super Bowl and the legendary "Ice Bowl" the following year. The Packers struggled through the 70s and 80s until returning to championship form again in the Brett Favre era.

While the 70s and 80s show that no teams' history is perfect, its tough to argue with 12 NFL Championships

19/20

Minnesota Vikings - A relatively young NFL franchise with their start in 1960, the Vikings captured their first NFL championship just 9 years later. The 1970s Vikings featured one of the greatest nicknames of all time (The Purple People Eaters) and Hall of Fame QB Fran Tarkenton. During the decade they won 8 division championships and appeared in 4 Super Bowls, but came up short each time.

It looked like the Vikings were headed for greatness in the late 90s behind Randy Moss's freakish talent and a young, promising Dante Culpepper but things took a turn for the worse with Culpepper plagued by injuries, the Randy Ratio, and the infamous Love Boat scandal.

The Vikings organization got off to a fast start in the 60s with their first and only NFL championship. Since then, they've been consistently competitive, but haven't gotten back to that championship level.

10/20

Enjoy your NFL Sunday and we'll continue with the History/Tradition breakdowns early next week as we move to the AFC South.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

A Tale of Three Teams - History and Tradition of the AFC North

As laid out in the points breakdown, one major category of the team ratings is History and Tradition. Some would argue the best way to predict a franchise's future is by looking at its past. This gets a lot tougher when comparing franchises who have been around for anywhere from 12 years to the NFL's inception, so keep in mind that we're not just looking at wins and losses (though it's definitely a big factor).  First, we'll take a look at a division with a historical juggernaut, a traditional punchline, and a team torn between two cities.

AFC North

Baltimore Ravens - And we start with one of the more complicated cases in all of the NFL - the history of the Baltimore Ravens. Baltimore football has a fairly rich history including three NFL Championships (pre-Super Bowl), 2 Super Bowl Championships, and Johnny Unitas. Unfortunately, all that history moved to Indianapolis in 1984. Another historic franchise, the Cleveland Browns moved to Baltimore in 1996. Unfortunately for Baltimore, the NFL ruled that the Browns name, history, and colors were to remain in Cleveland. In one of the more confusing decisions in Baltimore not involving Hamsterdam, the Ravens were effectively an expansion team despite bringing over the ownership, management, and player contracts from the Browns organization.

So, keeping with the NFL's ruling, the Ravens history starts in 1996. A short history for sure, but still a solid one. A franchise built around an aggressive, hard-hitting defense (and sometimes hard-to-stomach offense), the Ravens won a Super Bowl title in 2000, division championships in 03 and 06, and have 5 playoff appearances since 2000. Not bad for a 12 year old franchise.

Sure, they're technically lacking a long storied history, but what history they do have is impressive. It's tough to penalize them for the NFL's inconsistent treatment.

Score: 11/20

Cincinnati Bengals - Zero NFL Championships, a franchise record at 82 games below .500, a terrible draft history, and googling "Bengals" and "cursed" returns around 343,000 results. They were a drug relapse and dropped interception away from their first Super Bowl title in 1988. You'd be hard-pressed to find an "all time draft busts" list that doesn't include Akili Smith and Ki-Jana Carter. Their former head coach does run a steak house with his last name on it. Unfortunately, it has his Dad's picture on the logo.

More recent history hasn't been too kind to the Bengals, either. Their most promising season since the 80's ended with their franchise QB being carted off the field. When a Cincinnati police officer lets Ole Miss coach Andy Kennedy know arresting a big name such as himself is no big deal because "We deal with the Bengals all the time," well, that's not a good sign, either. Their latest first round draft pick holds out a month into the preseason, shows up about 30 pounds overweight, and then breaks his foot in a non-contact drill the first day back. But hey, a franchise can't really be cursed can it?


However, as I've said, this category isn't all about wins and losses. While the on-field success of the Bengals is probably deserving of the "Bungles" moniker, they have made their mark in one aspect of the NFL: the touchdown celebration. The Ickey Shuffle was revolutionary, controversial, and paved the way for guys like Deion Sanders, Terrell Owens, and the Bengals' own Chad Ochocino to put on the real show after they cross the goal line. In a franchise where so much has gone wrong, this has to count for something.

Score:  5/20

Cleveland Browns - As mentioned earlier, the history of the Cleveland Browns includes an interruption in service from 1996-1999 after Art Modell fled town to form the Ravens. Prior to 1996, their history is somewhat confusing to score. They dominated the AAFC all four years of its existence, winning all four titles. After joining the NFL in 1950 they won 4 championships before the NFL-AFL merger. However, since that time, they have failed to even appear in a Super Bowl.


Their history does include arguably the greatest football player in NFL history in Jim Brown. It also includes legendary moments such as "The Drive" and "The Fumble". Unfortunately for the Browns, they were on the short end of these plays and both kept them out of Super Bowls. Still, the Browns were a playoff mainstay in the late 80's behind Bernie Kosar. Once the 90s rolled around, things took a turn for the worse, bottoming out in 1996 but with almost no signs of contention since.

An early football powerhouse, possibly the greatest player of all time, and some legendary (but heartbreaking) moments...but failing to appear in a Super Bowl hurts.

Score: 9/20

Pittsburgh Steelers - If the Ravens were one of the harder franchises to score, Pittsburgh is one of the easiest. Six Super Bowl Championships, only three coaches since 1969, and one family owning the franchise since 1933. They brought us the Steel Curtain, the Immaculate Reception, and most importantly, Slash. It's pretty rare to hear a description of Steelers football that doesn't involve "hard-nosed". They're the epitome of stability. I don't want to understate this so let me repeat myself from earlier - they have had a total of THREE coaches since 1969 including the current one. Keep in mind that 7 NFL coaches were fired during 2008 alone and marinate in how impressive this stat is.

In fairness, Pittsburgh hasn't been dominant since its inception. The franchise won zero championships prior to the Chuck Noll era. They went through two badly named mergers with the Eagles (The Steagles) and the Cardinals (Card-Pitts, or Carpets) during World War 2. As the Steel Curtain retired, the team struggled in the mid to late 80s, missing the playoffs every year except one from 1985-1991. But really, isn't this grasping at straws for the team with the most Super Bowl Rings?

If it weren't for the "Steagles", Pittsburgh might have a perfect score here. They're still pretty close.

Score: 19/20

Next up is the NFC North. In the meantime, if anyone from Cleveland asks, you haven't seen me.