Monday, January 4, 2010

O.K., Now What? (and Current Make-Up Rankings of the AFC)

So time is of the essence here at SWF as I have less than a month to pick my NFL team and 14 remain in the hunt. The plan all along has been to get to a head-to-head style playoff here at the end of the season, and that's still the goal. To do that, however, we've got to a) cut some teams and b) establish some seeding.

With that in mind, here's the plan. We're going to follow the big-boys style of playoffs, with teams going head to head this week in a loser-goes-home elimination. Here's the problem - the NFL uses a 12 team playoff with 6 teams in each conference. We've got 14 teams remaining, and only 5 of those are in the NFC. So, with that in mind, I've got a decision to make. I can either a) eliminate 3 AFC teams and then pick a "wildcard" from the NFC or b) eliminate 2 AFC teams and send the lowest scoring NFC team to the AFC bracket or c) eliminate 3 AFC teams and then bring back from the dead the eliminated team with the highest voting total in the poll to the right, which as it stands now would be the *gulp* Detroit Lions...What do you think? I'll leave this open for discussion as of now...

Regardless, the teams also need to be seeded and I've still got 2 unscored categories. So, since time is short, I'm only scoring the 14 remaining teams in those categories for now (who knows, maybe I'll score the others just for fun later on). So with that in mind, onto the "Current Team Makeup"...

Current Team Make-Up AFC

Time's getting short here and the seedings need to be determined, so my words may be few here. Basically, this category ranks the teams on a 20 point scale based on how much I like the current team, from the coach to the players to the direction management has it heading, it's all fair game. See, I can pick a team based on every other category, but if I can't stand the current team, how is this supposed to stick? So onward we go...

Baltimore Ravens - 2 or 3 years ago, the Ravens bomb this category. Now? They're immensely more likable. Ray Rice is a stud, Ray Lewis is almost out the door, and Michael Oher almost made me cry during The Blindside. Not to mention their numerous Alabama ties between GM Ozzie Newsome, Leron McClain, and Jarrett Johnson.

16/20

Buffalo Bills - It's not Buffalo's fault that they're basically in television purgatory, but that's a tough team to follow from miles away. Without a coach or much of a QB, the team is in a little disarray. Of course, there's T.O., but does anyone really think he's a fixture here. Just not a roster I get overly excited about, but if they hire Bill Cowher I reserve the right to adjust this score.

5/20

Denver Broncos - Coach McDaniels has made himself the face of the team for better or worse. Who knows if Brandon Marshall sticks around and Kyle Orten isn't the flashiest QB in the league. It's tough to make a call on these guys this early considering the roller coaster year 1 was.

10/20

Indianapolis Colts - Honestly, the Colts makeup is dominated by one former Tennessee quarterback. He's the face of the franchise and that's not changing any time soon. Can an Alabama fan/alum hang his hat on a former Vol? Even if his commercials are pretty funny and at times the guy is pretty likable? Tough call.

8/20

Kansas City Chiefs - Another team in Year 1 of a new coach, new QB, as well as a new GM, so it's tough to draw too clear of a picture. They showed some life toward the end of the year, but they're definitely a team that's going to lose it's share of games over the next couple of years.

10/20

Miami Dolphins - I know they didn't make the playoffs and maybe their Wildcat attack was a flash in the pan, but I like these guys. How can you not love Tony Sporano and his sunglasses? If everyone is back healthy next year, they're going to be fun to watch, and how can you not love a team that has a partnership with Jimmy Buffet?

13/20

Pittsburgh Steelers - The Steelers have the coolest coach in the NFL and one of my favorite players in Troy Polamalu. You have to feel pretty good about the stability of everything with the Rooneys in charge.

15/20

San Diego Chargers - I don't tell many people this, but I like Phillip Rivers. Sure, he grew up about 30 minutes from me, but that's not the only reason. I like him for the very reason most people can't stand him. He's a little cocky and he runs his mouth a little much, but isn't it a little more fun when it's a QB doing that than a WR? On the other hand, I dislike few players more than Shawne Merriman (for a variety of reasons). I'd say LT is the tie-breaker, but I think we've just about seen the last of him.

11/20

Tennessee Titans - How can you not love Chris Johnson? Assuming that the Vince Young of the last half of the season is the one we get next year, that's a promising backfield. Jeff Fisher is likable and a true professional, even if he is a little too conservative from time to time.

12/20

6 comments:

  1. I just wanted to point out that if you gave TN a couple extra points for Chris Johnson you should really think about adding a few points to the Chiefs. Jamal Charles gained 1000+ yards and he only started half of the games. His performance yesterday was amazing. He is so much fun to watch.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agree with Anonymous(1). Jamaal Charles, I think, will be the next to break 2,000... You would be good to pick the Chiefs, they're going places. I say 8-8 next year.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hmm, this really is a tough decision. Now, I'm not sure what this head to head competition entails but I think the best way to get to it should be scenario B. Out of the bottom half of the AFC teams, I think you should eliminate 2 of them (all but one will be eliminated eventually anyway) and move the weakest NFC team over. Is this ideal? Probably not, but considering all the factors I'd say it's pretty damn close to as good as it might get.

    And by the way, option C doesn't make sense to me. I don't see how the Lions would be next in line.

    ReplyDelete
  4. spires: don't forget the titans have pro bowler courtland finnegan who played at a non D1 school (samford bulldogs) and tony brown from lowly memphis

    ReplyDelete
  5. oh, if you want a philip rivers autograph i'm sure i can persuade the sister-in-law to hook you up once their next family reunion rolls along

    p.s.: i think you should just put all the teams through a computer ranking and average w/ your current rankings...that seems to work in real life, right?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Just my bias as a bills fan, but how can you possibly out the chiefs at double our score and the buccaneers at 4 more than us when we have shown this year that we are better than these two teams. Sure they're young but we are also extremely young and this year we were killed by the injury bug. With 21 players (13 starters, yes truly 13) ending the year on injured reserve. We had an entire offensive line (5 players) on injured reserve. In conclusion I think that you have overlooked both our potential (our rookie Jairus Byrd didnt start until almost midway through the season, and was on IR for the last 2 games, but ended up with almost the league lead with 9 interceptions, young RB Fred Jackson led the league in all-purpose yards) and our bad luck (all the injures and our expected franchise QB, Trent Edwards, not panning out). With a proven head coach in place (talks are in place now to get a big name such as Bill Cowher or Marty Schottenheimer), legitimate QB (Expected to draft one in either the first or second round, also possibly signing a proven veteran), and frankly better luck, I feel that our team has the potential to be an extremely solid and probably play-off bound team. Or at least we have more potential for that than the chiefs (who we beat 16-10) and the buccaneers (who we beat 33-20).
    I'll stop droning on to say that I love this site and idea and I hope that you become of a fan of a team that best suits you.
    Thanks and go bills,

    Xavier

    ReplyDelete

Let me hear your thoughts on who is the right (or wrong) team for me. In order to keep SWF family friendly, please avoid the use of profanity.